Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Letter to Senator Specter

Greetings,

Firstly, welcome to the Democratic Party! Secondly, I would like to voice my own opinion on marriage equality. Marriage has many connotations, and most of them, today are associated with love, children, and some sort of religious ceremony. However, people have the choice to be married by a justice of the peace, outside of any religious settings. Additionally, marriage has not always been a religious institution, and was, not so long ago, a property agreement. A man sold his daughter to another man, usually with a bit of money and some cows, in hopes that this man would be able to get some sort of return for his purchase, usually in the form of a son and heir. Marriage was a means of establishing paternity, prior to having actual DNA testing. Seldom was love involved, and in many nations today, arranged marriages with dowries still exist and are the norm. These marriages happen in places that do not necessarily practice any sort of organized religion, or often, some other religion besides Christianity. Marriage is not a Christian institution.

Outside of the religious connotations most people tact on to marriage, there are many (1138, to be exact) rights granted to married couples that are not given to non-married couples. In this country, at least, there is a governmental aspect to marriage. Many will argue that marriage, when between a male and a female, creates the perfect environment for child-rearing, and by protecting traditional marriage, you are protecting the children. If this is the case, why is divorce legal? Should we work to make divorce illegal, since it deprives a child of a mother and a father, the way a homosexual marriage would? Should single mothers be forced into wedlock, so that their children can have a father, or visa versa? Should those too old to produce children, say those re-marrying after being widowed, not be allowed, since their union cannot produce children? Others will argue that their religious liberties will be taken away should same-sex marriage be legalized. The LGBT community does not, and will not seek to have any religious organization, preacher, reverend, priest, minister, or other religiously affiliated individual be forced by law into performing a marriage against their will. Those individuals already have the power to deny a marriage in their church to heterosexual couples, should they feel that the marriage is not for the right reasons. Many reverends and preachers have marriage counselling for straight couples, and at the end of the counselling can decide that they do not want to marry the couple.

Just as that freedom should be granted to religious organizations, the freedom from religion should be granted to those who seek it. There are many in this nation who are not Christian, whether they be agnostic or belong to some other recognized religion, they are not bound to follow the Bible. As such, the views of the Bible should not be forced upon the nation. Many call on a line in Leviticus to prove that God hates homosexuals. While I am not Christian myself, I thought the primary theme in the Bible was that God loved all of his children; he loved them so much that he gave to them his only son, Jesus Christ, and that Jesus taught us to love our neighbor, to not judge, and to be tolerant. The well quoted line in Leviticus, however, is taken out of context. The line is an old Jewish honor code, not Jewish law. The ancient Jews had no concept of how a child is conceived, and thought that for semen to be spilled anywhere except in a woman was to waste it; that semen was limited in supply and that since Jews had a small population, that it could not be wasted by either masturbation or by a man lying with a man as he would with a woman. It was not a condemnation of homosexuals, but rather a condemnation of wasting what they thought was limited resources. The same honor code goes on to condemn wearing fabrics of mixed fiber (cotton/polyester blends that are so common today), eating shellfish (no more shrimp), and many other practices we find common today. The Bible also says in the Old Testament that you can stone your wife to death if you find out she was not a virgin on your wedding day, that if a husband dies without a son and heir, his widow must sleep with his brothers until she bears him an heir, and that a daughter can be sold into slavery or prostitution. A lot of Christians today ignore these rules, saying that Jesus preached love, and that these old Jewish honor codes of the Old Testament do not need to be followed.

Others argue that being homosexual is a choice, and that it is therefore not a suspect classification that should be protected by the 14th Amendment. If being homosexual is a choice, then there must be a point in everyones life where they think about that choice, and decide whether they want to be straight, or whether they want to be gay. There then must be people who choose to be straight, and people who choose to be gay. I then ask the straight people "when did you first know you where straight? When did you decide to be straight?" There are many people on both sides who try to uphold biology and genetics to make the case that either homosexuals are born that way, or they are not. There are some in the middle who say that genetics plays a role, but so does upbringing. We do not know the cause, if there is a cause, for homosexuality. Conversely, that means we do not know the cause, if there is one, for heterosexuality. Regardless, homosexuals and the queer community are people capable of forming long lasting relationships built on trust, understanding, compassion, and honesty. We wish for those relationships to be recognized. I want to know that I can name my partner in my will, and know that my family cannot try to take away what I left for her, I want to know that I can visit her in the hospital should she become ill. I want to know that she, who knows me best, will be allowed to make medical decisions for me should I come into a state where I cannot make them for myself. Many in the LGBT community have been shunned by their parents, and the parents have not talked to them in years. These parents do not know the wishes of their children, but their partners do. Why should the partners, whom they may be living with or planning on moving to one of the six states that have legalized same-sex marriage, be allowed to make these important decisions over the partner?

If you do not at least agree on this, you should agree to legislation that will ban discrimination within the work place, and other places where discrimination may occur. There are many who fear that they will not be hired if the employer knew they were gay, and others who constantly fear that they will be fired if their orientation were known. Hate crimes continue to plague the LGBT community, and legislation that would identify these crimes for what they are would be a step in the right direction to guaranteeing freedom and equality to everyone. There are many who have to keep silent about who they are, and have to at times deny who they are, such as the queer men and women currently serving in the military who cannot talk about their sexuality. Repealing "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" and the Defense of Marriage Act are huge hurdles in granting equality to all. After a campaign promising the LGBT community that he would work on our side, President Obama has taken a step backwards, in a time when so many states, Iowa, New Jersey, New York, and others, are taking huge steps forward.

I hope that you, Senator Specter, are one of those willing to take a step forward and defend the Constitutional promise of equality as found in the 14th Amendment.

No comments:

Post a Comment